STATE OF MINNESOTA FORTIETH MEETING
HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES EIGHTY-SIXTH SESSION
TAX COMMITTEE
MINUTES
Representative Lenczewski, Chair of the Committee, called meeting to order at 9:14 AM on Tuesday, April 21, 2009 in Room 10 of the State Office Building.
The Committee Legislative Assistant noted the roll:
Members Present:
LENCZEWSKI, Ann (Chair)
ANDERSON, Sarah
BROD, Laura
CARLSON, Lyndon
DAVIDS, Greg
DAVNIE, Jim
DEMMER, Randy
DILL, David
DITTRICH, Denise
DOWNEY, Keith
EASTLUND, Rob
GARDNER, Paul
GAROFALO, Patrick
HILSTROM, Debra
KOENEN, Lyle
KOHLS, Paul
LANNING, Morrie
LESCH, John
LIEBLING, Tina
LOEFFLER, Diane
LOON, Jenifer
MARQUART, Paul
MULLERY, Joe
MURPHY, Erin
REINERT, Roger
RUKAVINA, Tom
RUUD, Maria
SOLBERG, Loren
TILLBERRY, Tom
ZELLERS, Kurt
A quorum was present
Representative Lenczewski, Chair of the Committee, moves that HF2323 be recommended to pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on Ways and Means.
HF2323-Lenczewski-Income and corporate franchise tax federal update provided.
Representative Loeffler moved amendment
H2323A4 for adoption. THE MOTION PREVAILED. THE AMENDMENT WAS ADOPTED.
Representative Reinert moved amendment
PMA11 for adoption. THE MOTION DID NOT PREVAIL. THE AMENDMENT WAS NOT ADOPTED.
Representative S. Anderson moved amendment
H2323A19 for adoption.
Representative S. Anderson requested a roll call. The clerk took the roll on the amendment:
LENCZEWSKI, Ann (Chair) NAY
ANDERSON, Sarah AYE
BROD, Laura AYE
CARLSON, Lyndon NAY
DAVIDS, Greg AYE
DAVNIE, Jim NAY
DEMMER, Randy AYE
DILL, David excused
DITTRICH, Denise NAY
DOWNEY, Keith AYE
EASTLUND, Rob AYE
GARDNER, Paul AYE
GAROFALO, Patrick AYE
HILSTROM, Debra NAY
KOENEN, Lyle NAY
KOHLS, Paul AYE
LANNING, Morrie excused
LESCH, John NAY
LIEBLING, Tina NAY
LOEFFLER, Diane NAY
LOON, Jenifer AYE
MARQUART, Paul NAY
MULLERY, Joe NAY
MURPHY, Erin NAY
REINERT, Roger AYE
RUKAVINA, Tom NAY
RUUD, Maria AYE
SOLBERG, Loren NAY
TILLBERRY, Tom NAY
ZELLERS, Kurt AYE
There being 13 ayes and 15 nays, THE MOTION DID NOT PREVAIL. THE AMENDMENT WAS NOT ADOPTED.
Representative Brod moved amendment
H2323A18 for adoption.
Representative Brod withdrew amendment H2323A18.
Representative Zellers moved amendment
H2323A11.
Representative Zellers requested a roll call. The clerk took the roll on the amendment:
LENCZEWSKI, Ann (Chair) Nay
ANDERSON, Sarah Aye
BROD, Laura Aye
CARLSON, Lyndon Nay
DAVIDS, Greg Aye
DAVNIE, Jim Nay
DEMMER, Randy Aye
DILL, David Nay
DITTRICH, Denise Aye
DOWNEY, Keith Aye
EASTLUND, Rob Aye
GARDNER, Paul Nay
GAROFALO, Patrick Aye
HILSTROM, Debra Nay
KOENEN, Lyle Nay
KOHLS, Paul Aye
LANNING, Morrie excused
LESCH, John Nay
LIEBLING, Tina Nay
LOEFFLER, Diane Nay
LOON, Jenifer Aye
MARQUART, Paul Nay
MULLERY, Joe Nay
MURPHY, Erin Nay
REINERT, Roger Nay
RUKAVINA, Tom Nay
RUUD, Maria Aye
SOLBERG, Loren Nay
TILLBERRY, Tom Nay
ZELLERS, Kurt Aye
There being 12 Ayes and 17 Nays, THE MOTION DID NOT PREVAIL, THE AMENDMENT WAS NOT ADOPTED.
Representative Rukavina moved amendment
H2323A13 for adoption.
Representative Garofalo moved to divide amendment H2323A13 as follows: divide between lines 1.19 and 1.20 THE MOTION PREVAILED.
Representative Garofalo moved lines 1.3 to 1.19 for adoption.
Representative Anderson requested a roll call. The clerk took the roll on lines 1.3 to 1.19 in amendment H2323A13:
LENCZEWSKI, Ann (Chair) Nay
ANDERSON, Sarah Nay
BROD, Laura Nay
CARLSON, Lyndon Nay
DAVIDS, Greg Nay
DAVNIE, Jim Nay
DEMMER, Randy Nay
DILL, David Aye
DITTRICH, Denise Nay
DOWNEY, Keith Nay
EASTLUND, Rob Nay
GARDNER, Paul Nay
GAROFALO, Patrick Nay
HILSTROM, Debra Nay
KOENEN, Lyle Aye
LANNING, Morrie excused
LESCH, John Aye
LIEBLING, Tina Nay
LOEFFLER, Diane Nay
LOON, Jenifer Nay
MARQUART, Paul Nay
MULLERY, Joe Nay
MURPHY, Erin Nay
REINERT, Roger Aye
RUKAVINA, Tom Aye
RUUD, Maria Nay
SOLBERG, Loren Aye
TILLBERRY, Tom Nay
ZELLERS, Kurt Nay
There being 6 Ayes and 23 Nays, THE MOTION DID NOT PREVAIL, LINES 1.3 TO 1.19 WERE NOT ADOPTED.
Representative Lenczewski ruled lines 1.20 to 2.7 in amendment H2323A13 out of order.
Representative Kohls moved amendment
H2323A15.
Representative Kohls requested a roll call.
Representative Kohls moved to incorporate an oral amendment to amendment H2323A15 as follows: line 2.24, after the word "effective" insert "for individuals who retire after"
The clerk took the roll on the amendment as incorporated:
LENCZEWSKI, Ann (Chair) Nay
ANDERSON, Sarah Aye
BROD, Laura Aye
CARLSON, Lyndon Nay
DAVIDS, Greg Aye
DAVNIE, Jim Nay
DEMMER, Randy Aye
DILL, David Nay
DITTRICH, Denise Nay
DOWNEY, Keith Aye
EASTLUND, Rob Aye
GARDNER, Paul Nay
GAROFALO, Patrick Aye
HILSTROM, Debra Nay
KOENEN, Lyle Nay
KOHLS, Paul Aye
LANNING, Morrie excused
LESCH, John Nay
LIEBLING, Tina Nay
LOEFFLER, Diane Nay
LOON, Jenifer Aye
MARQUART, Paul Nay
MULLERY, Joe Nay
MURPHY, Erin Nay
REINERT, Roger Nay
RUKAVINA, Tom Nay
RUUD, Maria Nay
SOLBERG, Loren Nay
TILLBERRY, Tom Nay
ZELLERS, Kurt Aye
There being 10 Ayes and 19 Nays, THE MOTION DID NOT PREVAIL; THE AMENDMENT WAS NOT ADOPTED.
Representative Dill moved amendment
KN-A10 for adoption. THE MOTION PREVAILED, THE AMENDMENT WAS ADOPTED.
Representative Demmer moved amendment
H2323A12 for adoption.
Representative Demmer requested a roll call. The clerk took the roll on the amendment:
LENCZEWSKI, Ann (Chair) Nay
ANDERSON, Sarah Aye
BROD, Laura Aye
CARLSON, Lyndon Nay
DAVIDS, Greg excused
DAVNIE, Jim Nay
DEMMER, Randy Aye
DILL, David Nay
DITTRICH, Denise Nay
DOWNEY, Keith Aye
EASTLUND, Rob Aye
GARDNER, Paul Nay
GAROFALO, Patrick Aye
HILSTROM, Debra Nay
KOENEN, Lyle Nay
KOHLS, Paul Aye
LANNING, Morrie excused
LESCH, John Nay
LIEBLING, Tina Nay
LOEFFLER, Diane Nay
LOON, Jenifer Aye
MARQUART, Paul Nay
MULLERY, Joe Nay
MURPHY, Erin Nay
REINERT, Roger Nay
RUKAVINA, Tom Nay
RUUD, Maria Nay
SOLBERG, Loren Nay
TILLBERRY, Tom Nay
ZELLERS, Kurt Aye
There being 9 Ayes and 19 Nays, THE MOTION DID NOT PREVAIL; THE AMENDMENT WAS NOT ADOPTED.
Representative Eastlund moved amendment
H2323A20 for adoption.
Representative Eastlund requested a roll call. The clerk took the roll on the amendment:
LENCZEWSKI, Ann (Chair) Nay
ANDERSON, Sarah Aye
BROD, Laura Aye
CARLSON, Lyndon Nay
DAVIDS, Greg Aye
DAVNIE, Jim Nay
DEMMER, Randy Aye
DILL, David Aye
DITTRICH, Denise Nay
DOWNEY, Keith Aye
EASTLUND, Rob Aye
GARDNER, Paul Nay
GAROFALO, Patrick Aye
HILSTROM, Debra Nay
KOENEN, Lyle Nay
KOHLS, Paul Aye
LANNING, Morrie excused
LESCH, John Nay
LIEBLING, Tina Nay
LOEFFLER, Diane Nay
LOON, Jenifer Aye
MARQUART, Paul Nay
MULLERY, Joe Nay
MURPHY, Erin Nay
REINERT, Roger Aye
RUKAVINA, Tom Aye
RUUD, Maria Nay
SOLBERG, Loren Aye
TILLBERRY, Tom Nay
ZELLERS, Kurt Aye
There being 14 Ayes and 15 Nays, THE MOTION DID NOT PREVAIL, THE AMENDMENT WAS NOT ADOPTED.
Representative Loon moved amendment
H2323A31 for adoption.
Representative Loon requested a roll call. The clerk took the roll on the amendment:
LENCZEWSKI, Ann (Chair) Nay
ANDERSON, Sarah Aye
BROD, Laura Aye
CARLSON, Lyndon Nay
DAVIDS, Greg Aye
DAVNIE, Jim Nay
DEMMER, Randy Aye
DILL, David Nay
DITTRICH, Denise Nay
DOWNEY, Keith Aye
EASTLUND, Rob Aye
GARDNER, Paul Nay
GAROFALO, Patrick Aye
HILSTROM, Debra Nay
KOENEN, Lyle Nay
KOHLS, Paul Aye
LANNING, Morrie excused
LESCH, John Nay
LIEBLING, Tina Nay
LOEFFLER, Diane Nay
LOON, Jenifer Aye
MARQUART, Paul Nay
MULLERY, Joe Nay
MURPHY, Erin Nay
REINERT, Roger Nay
RUKAVINA, Tom Nay
RUUD, Maria Nay
SOLBERG, Loren Nay
TILLBERRY, Tom Nay
ZELLERS, Kurt Aye
There being 10 Ayes and 19 Nays, THE MOTION DID NOT PREVAIL; THE AMENDMENT WAS NOT ADOPTED.
Representative Tillberry moved amendment
A09-0427X for adoption. THE MOTION DID NOT PREVAIL; THE AMENDMENT WAS NOT ADOPTED.
Representative Garofalo moved amendment
H2323A28 for adoption. THE MOTION PREVAILED, THE AMENDMENT WAS ADOPTED.
Representative Gardner moved amendment
HF2323A22 for adoption. THE MOTION PREVAILED, THE AMENDMENT WAS ADOPTED.
Representative Koenen moved amendment
H2323A30 for adoption. THE MOTION PREVAILED, THE AMENDMENT WAS ADOPTED.
Representative Lenczewski moved amendment
H2323A32 for adoption. THE MOTION PREVAILED, THE AMENDMENT WAS ADOPTED.
Representative Demmer moved amendment
H2323A23 for adoption. THE MOTION DID NOT PREVAIL; THE AMENDMENT WAS NOT ADOPTED.
Representative Demmer called for a division. There being 17 Nays and 10 Ayes, THE MOTION DID NOT PREVAIL; THE AMENDMENT WAS NOT ADOPTED.
Representative Dill moved amendment
H2323A40 for adoption. THE MOTION PREVAILED, THE AMENDMENT WAS ADOPTED.
Representative Rukavina moved amendment
H2323A7 for adoption.
Representative Rukavina moved to incorporate an oral amendment as follows: delete lines 1.6 to 1.19
Representative Rukavina renewed his motion to adopt amendment H2323A7 as orally amended. THE MOTION PREVAILED,THE AMENDMENT WAS ADOPTED AS ORALLY AMENDED.
Representative Lenczewski renewed her motion that HF2323 be recommended to pass as amended and be sent to the Committee on Ways and Means.
Representative Brod requested a roll call. The clerk took the roll on the bill as amended:
LENCZEWSKI, Ann (Chair) Aye
ANDERSON, Sarah Nay
BROD, Laura Nay
CARLSON, Lyndon Aye
DAVIDS, Greg Nay
DAVNIE, Jim Aye
DEMMER, Randy Nay
DILL, David Aye
DITTRICH, Denise Nay
DOWNEY, Keith Nay
EASTLUND, Rob Nay
GARDNER, Paul Nay
GAROFALO, Patrick Nay
HILSTROM, Debra Aye
KOENEN, Lyle Aye
KOHLS, Paul Nay
LANNING, Morrie Nay
LESCH, John Aye
LIEBLING, Tina Aye
LOEFFLER, Diane Aye
LOON, Jenifer Nay
MARQUART, Paul Aye
MULLERY, Joe Aye
MURPHY, Erin Aye
REINERT, Roger Aye
RUKAVINA, Tom Aye
RUUD, Maria Nay
SOLBERG, Loren Aye
TILLBERRY, Tom Aye
ZELLERS, Kurt Nay
There being 16 Ayes and 14 Nays, THE BILL IS PASSED AND SENT TO THE COMMITTEE ON WAYS AND MEANS.
Representative Lenczewski, Chair of the Committee, adjourned the meeting at 1:10 PM.
________________________________________
Representative Ann Lenczewski, Chair
________________________________________
Sasha Bergman, Committee Legislative Assistant