Skip to main content Skip to office menu Skip to footer
Capital IconMinnesota Legislature

House panel sends bill that would limit train length to next stop

(House Photography file photo)
(House Photography file photo)

Waiting at train crossings can be a daily inconvenience for some people.  However, if you are in an ambulance and the train is 2 or 3 miles long, waiting risks more than being late for a movie.

Preventing ultralong trains from cutting communities in half for minutes, and sometimes hours, is one of the impetuses behind HF3499, which calls for a limit on train length to 8,500 feet — about 1.5 miles.

House transportation committee approves bill to limit train length to 8,500 feet 3/12/24

Sponsored by Rep. Jeff Brand (DFL-St. Peter), it was approved Tuesday by the House Transportation Finance and Policy Committee on a 9-6 party-line vote and sent to the House Judiciary Finance and Civil Law Committee. The bill, as amended, also would require increased insurance coverage when crews travel to work and includes penalties for failing to do so.

The bill, along with a few other Brand bills heard by the committee, aim to have the state improve safety for railroad workers and communities in areas where the federal government has failed to act.

Longer trains are more difficult to drive and can be too big for existing infrastructure. Trainyards and terminals do not have the capacity to handle 2- or 3-mile trains and that can cause hours-long backups, said Joel Mueller, chair of the Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers and Trainmen Division 9.

More freight cars have the potential to cause much more damage if they do crash.

Bill opponents, however, say the limit would put more trains on the tracks, cause congestion delays and unnecessarily drive up costs for all consumers. As an example, they said imagine a freight train carrying goods from California having to stop and remove cars when it gets to the Minnesota border.

Moreover, an 8,500-foot limit is arbitrary and ignores technological improvements which have significantly decreased the number of derailments.

Rep. John Petersburg (R-Waseca) isn’t convinced the Legislature is best positioned to decide train length. He noted increased size in other shipping industries, but said any business is leery about adding more risk.


Related Articles


Priority Dailies

Minnesota's budget outlook worsens in both near, long term
Gov. Tim Walz takes questions following the release of the state's November budget forecast in December 2024. The latest projections show a $456 million surplus in the current budget cycle and a $6 billion deficit longer-term. (House Photography file photo) It looks as if those calling for less state spending could get their wish, judging from Thursday’s release of the February 2025 Budget and Economic Forecast. A state su...
Full House convenes for first time in 2025, elects Demuth speaker
Rep. Jeff Backer, left and Rep. Matt Norris greet each other on the House floor Feb. 6. House DFLers returned to the House Chamber for the first time during the 2025 session after leaders struck a power-sharing agreement. (Photo by Michele Jokinen) DFL, Republicans convene with a quorum for the first time in 2025 session after agreeing to a power-sharing deal.

Minnesota House on Twitter